CAN YOU REPLACE ONLY THE BRAKE PADS AND NOT THE ROTORS?

June 25, 2019

Lori Drouillard

Because brakes are such an essential part of a vehicle’s operation, every mechanic – be he/she a DIYer or a professional – should take servicing these life savers seriously. However, this does not mean that there aren’t some people who are willing to take shortcuts when it comes to replacing/serving this vital safety component. What we are referring to is the practice of “pad slapping’ which means replacing only the brake pads as opposed to replacing the pads and rotors when needed. At Autohaus we believe that a job worth doing is worth doing well. Here are some things you need to know about pad slapping and why we do not recommend this practice.

Reasons to Replace Rotors and Brake Pads

A car’s braking system is an intricate interplay of various machines parts that work in conjunction with one another. Neglecting one component of this system can compromise your vehicle’s ability to stop when necessary. Here are some reasons to replace all components of your braking system.

  • Rotors are much thinner: Rotors nowadays are made thinner and are not able to be resurfaced like they were years ago.

  • It’s nearly impossible to perfectly resurface old rotors: Rotors that can be resurfaced are never as efficient as brand new rotors. Therefore, pad slapping can leave other components of your braking system in disrepair.

  • Pads and Rotors should wear at the same rate: Because the pads and rotors are designed to wear at approximately the same rate, if only the pads are replaced, the worn rotors can begin to cut a groove into the new pads, which will cause premature wear of the brake pads.

  • Your brakes will not be as efficient: Replacing only the pads and not replacing damaged rotors will reduce your vehicle’s stopping ability because it is likely that the rotors will be used beyond their minimum width.

  • You will end up paying more for brake service by paying for labor twice: If you choose to have only the pads replaced now, then a few months from now, you may need to have the rotors replaced. You will have to pay the same amount of labor to do the rotors at a later time, so it only makes sense to do the whole job at one time.

The Ideal Brake Job

The best chance for consumers to get good results when having their brakes replaced is to make sure that the mechanic does a thorough job and does not cut corners. An honest mechanic will tell you exactly which components need to be replaced. He or she will also be able to show you the parts that need to be replaced and how they differ from new, more reliable parts.

We, at Autohaus, understand that some people may consider pad slapping from a money saving perspective only. However, you can’t put a price on safety. The damage that you can do to yourself, your passengers, your vehicle and the passengers of other vehicles can far outweigh the short term savings in repair fees. So, the next time you experience brake squeal/squeak,  brake pulsationbrake grinding  or your brake pad warning light comes on, it may be that you need to have your pads and rotors replaced.

A brake fluid flush is a necessary maintenance service that is required every two years, regardless of mileage on most vehicles. Although it will not solve the major issues involving your braking system, it is important to keep the fluid fresh for optimal breaking.

If you are experiencing brake issues, give us a call at 248-971-7789. We are here Monday through Thursday 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM and Friday 8:00 AM to 3:00 PM to take care of all of your vehicle’s needs. Autohaus serves the Royal Oak and greater Metro Detroit area, including Birmingham, Beverly Hills, Franklin, Farmington Hills, Clawson, Berkley, Oak Park and the surrounding areas.

By Lori Drouillard April 9, 2026
If your Porsche hesitates between gears, jerks during shifts, slips unexpectedly, or refuses to engage drive or reverse smoothly, the transmission valve body is one of the first places a qualified Porsche specialist checks. Valve body failure is a well-documented issue on Porsche’s PDK and Tiptronic transmission platforms — and it’s a repair that demands […] The post Where To Go in Royal Oak to Tackle Porsche Transmission Valve Body Failure appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.
By Lori Drouillard March 13, 2026
If you are driving a Volkswagen, then you know they are engineered for performance, comfort, and innovation. However, like any other car, Volkswagens may encounter problems over time, and one such problem is the failure of the fuel pressure regulators. If you are in the Royal Oak, MI, area and something suspiciously wrong with your […] The post Where Should You Go in Royal Oak To Address Volkswagen Fuel Pressure Regulator Failure appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.
By Lori Drouillard February 10, 2026
A high-end car like the Audi signals that you value style, enjoy strong performance, and prefer a vehicle built with high-quality engineering. But even a solid and well-built engine wears down eventually. Whether you are driving through Royal Oak, Michigan (MI), or stuck in heavy traffic, the condition of your engine directly affects your car’s […] The post Top Signs Your Audi Needs Immediate Engine Service in Royal Oak appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.
By Lori Drouillard January 17, 2026
When you buy an Audi, you expect superior performance, precise German engineering, high-tech utility, a sleek, luxurious aesthetic, and unparalleled safety. Safety features define the car’s drivability, establishing driver and passenger safety and trust. The brake system is a crucial component, without which the vehicle’s safety is incomplete. Several brake-related malfunctions and issues go unnoticed […] The post Brake Problems Royal Oak Audi Drivers Should Never Ignore appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.
By Lori Drouillard December 22, 2025
BMW vehicles are a masterful blend of performance, luxury, and precision engineering. With advanced tech integration, fine-tuned vehicle systems, and superior performance mechanics, the vehicles are testaments to sophisticated engineering, with a very low tolerance for irregularities and malfunctions. That’s why you need certified mechanics with specialized expertise and training in BMW vehicles, ensuring accurate, […] The post What to Look For When Choosing Certified BMW Mechanics appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.
By Lori Drouillard November 19, 2025
Owning a Mercedes-Benz is about experiencing the pinnacle of automotive engineering, luxury, and performance. However, to maintain high-quality vehicle performance, you must have Mercedes maintenance services performed. These maintenance services fine-tune the car, remove accumulated debris, and detect and repair malfunctions before they worsen. The Importance of Mercedes Maintenance Autohaus Service and Sales has been […] The post Why Routine Mercedes Maintenance Matters For Royal Oak Drivers appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.
By Lori Drouillard October 14, 2025
For Audi owners, the smooth, responsive, and precise handling is an important part of their driving experience. The steering system requires attention to prevent common issues that can compromise the safety and performance. Routine maintenance is crucial in combating wear and tear from daily driving. Specific proactive steps need to be taken, including checking fluid […] The post How Royal Oak Audi Owners Can Prevent Steering Problems appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.
By Lori Drouillard September 13, 2025
Is your Volkswagen transmission system due for inspection? If you cannot recall the last time the transmission on your Volkswagen was checked and serviced, it is high time that you did so. Your car’s transmission system is among the most essential parts since it is in charge of moving power from the engine to the […] The post Top 5 Reasons To Prioritize Transmission Service For Your Volkswagen appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.
By Lori Drouillard August 13, 2025
Porsche is one of the most sought-after high-end sports cars, evoking awe and envy from passersby and competitors alike. No doubt, buying a Porsche is a proud moment; however, the joy of driving these luxury cars can be short-lived when you encounter issues, especially water pump failure in the case of Porsche. The water pump […] The post What Are Some Tips To Detect Porsche Water Pump Leaks? appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.
By Lori Drouillard July 13, 2025
The half-shaft boot is a critical component of the drivetrain that covers the CV joints. To understand the significance of the half-shaft boot, it is crucial to understand the function of the CV joint. The CV joint assists in the transfer of power from the transmission to the wheels. Additionally, it maintains the wheel’s rotation […] The post Tips To Prevent Volkswagen Half-Shaft Boot Failure appeared first on Autohaus Service And Sales.